140. CCA Study Notes: Depression vs. Dementia, Shared Symptoms and Supporting Clients

The Big Picture

Depression and dementia can affect how a person thinks, feels, and behaves. Some signs look so similar that it can be difficult to tell the conditions apart.

A person with depression does not necessarily develop dementia. A person with dementia may also have depression, or may show behaviours that look like depression without having it.

Understanding these differences helps you recognize why an accurate diagnosis matters and how to support a client who is experiencing depression while living with dementia.

Look for Nova Scotia CCA Notes throughout this page for current provincial guidance.

Quick tip: Tap, click, or press Enter on any term with a dotted underline and an ⓘ icon to see its plain-English definition.

Jump to:

Course Notes: Key Ideas You Need to Know

Understanding Depression and Dementia

Dementia is a general term for a group of illnesses that cause a progressive loss of brain functions. Progressive means the loss increases over time.

Dementia can affect:

  • Memory
  • Thinking
  • Learning
  • Behaviour
  • Communication
  • Social functioning

Dementia is not one single disease. Depending on its symptoms, it is classified as either a mild or major neurocognitive disorder.

Alzheimer’s disease and related dementias (ADRD) is a term used for Alzheimer’s disease and related conditions. Alzheimer’s disease is the most common form of dementia.

Alzheimer’s disease gradually damages nerve cells, called neurons, throughout most areas of the brain. Thinking and memory become seriously impaired as the disease progresses.

How Depression Can Resemble Dementia

Depression and dementia can have similar signs and symptoms. This sometimes makes it difficult to recognize which condition a person is experiencing.

Pseudo-dementia means false dementia. It occurs when severe depression causes changes in thinking that resemble dementia.

A person experiencing pseudo-dementia may appear to have dementia because of these thinking changes.

Key difference: Depression does not mean that a person will eventually develop dementia. The causes of major depression and dementia may be completely unrelated.

Delirium Can Also Be Confused With Dementia

Delirium is a temporary state of mental disorientation that can begin suddenly.

Delirium, depression, and dementia share some signs and symptoms. This means that delirium or depression may be mistaken for dementia.

Remember these differences:

  • Dementia: Involves a progressive loss of brain functions.
  • Delirium: Involves temporary mental disorientation that can appear suddenly.
  • Pseudo-dementia: Involves thinking changes caused by severe depression that resemble dementia.

These terms describe different conditions, even though some of their symptoms overlap.

Symptoms Shared by Depression and Dementia

Depression and dementia can both affect a person’s interest in daily life, relationships, and thinking.

Five symptoms can occur with either condition:

  1. Lack of concern for surroundings: The person seems less interested in what is happening around them.
  2. Loss of interest in activities and hobbies: Activities the person previously enjoyed no longer hold the same interest.
  3. Social withdrawal and isolation: The person pulls away from social contact or spends time apart from others.
  4. Trouble concentrating: The person has difficulty keeping their attention on something.
  5. Impaired thinking: The person’s ability to think is affected.

These symptoms alone do not establish whether a person has depression or dementia.

Some people in the early stages of ADRD may seem depressed even when they are not. Their dementia symptoms can resemble depression closely enough to cause confusion.

Depression and Dementia Can Occur Together

Depression and dementia are different conditions, but a person can experience both.

Number to remember: Experts estimate that up to 40% of people with ADRD also experience major depressive disorder.

This means that symptoms resembling depression should not automatically be explained as dementia alone.

Depression in an older person is always a significant concern for health care providers. An accurate diagnosis by a physician is important.

Why Depression Can Be Harder to Recognize in Clients With ADRD

A person living with dementia may have difficulty expressing feelings associated with depression.

They may be less likely to tell others about:

  • Sadness
  • Hopelessness
  • Guilt
  • Other feelings connected with depression

Depression can also look different in someone with ADRD than in someone without it.

Differences in Depression Symptoms

Depression in people with ADRD may show these patterns:

  • Shorter duration: Depression symptoms may not last as long as dementia symptoms increase.
  • Symptoms that come and go: Depression symptoms may appear, disappear, and return.
  • Less severe symptoms: Depression may be less severe in people with ADRD.
  • Talking about or attempting suicide: People with ADRD may be less likely to talk about suicide or attempt it.

These differences can make depression more difficult to diagnose in a person living with dementia.

Diagnosis and Treatment of Depression in ADRD

An accurate diagnosis by a physician is important because depression and dementia can produce similar symptoms.

Receiving appropriate diagnosis and treatment for depression can significantly improve the quality of life of someone living with ADRD.

Treatment involves a combination of:

  • Medication: Medicines included in depression treatment.
  • Counselling
  • Encouraged socialization: Encouraging interaction with other people.
  • Activities: Encouraging participation in activities.

These are treatment approaches. The next section focuses on ways to support a client in daily life.

Supporting a Client Living With Dementia Who Is Depressed

Support focuses on creating a predictable daily routine, encouraging activities, recognizing feelings, and offering reassurance.

The following approaches can help support a client experiencing both dementia and depression.

Create a Predictable Daily Routine

A regular schedule gives the client a consistent daily routine.

Supportive approaches include:

  • Plan a predictable routine: Keep the client’s daily activities on a regular schedule.
  • Choose the client’s best time: Schedule high-energy activities, such as bathing, when the client is at their best.
  • Encourage regular exercise: Assist the client with exercising regularly, particularly in the morning.

Key fact: Higher-energy activities should be scheduled during the client’s best time of day.

Encourage Enjoyable Activities and Social Contact

Help the client continue participating in activities and experiences they enjoy.

Supportive approaches include:

  • Identify favourite activities: Make a list of activities the client enjoys and arrange them more often.
  • Include enjoyable people and places: Identify people the client likes spending time with and places they enjoy visiting. Schedule these experiences more frequently.
  • Consider a support group : Encourage participation in a support group when appropriate. Support groups are especially helpful to clients in the early stages of dementia.
  • Offer favourite foods: Include foods the client enjoys.

These approaches focus on the client’s own interests and preferences.

Acknowledge Feelings and Offer Reassurance

Emotional support is another important part of caring for someone living with dementia and depression.

Supportive approaches include:

  • Recognize the client’s feelings: Acknowledge and validate sadness or frustration. Validation means recognizing the client’s feelings as real and important.
  • Express hope: Frequently communicate your hope that the client will feel better soon.
  • Celebrate small successes: Recognize small achievements and special occasions.
  • Reassure the client of their value: Remind the client that they are loved, respected, and appreciated within their family.
  • Offer reassurance about abandonment: Reassure the client that they will not be abandoned.

Emotional reassurance should be respectful and connected to what the client is feeling.

Some ideas about depression and dementia are easy to confuse. Keep these differences clear.

Wrong IdeaBetter Idea
Depression means a person will eventually develop dementia.The causes may be unrelated. Depression does not mean dementia will develop.
Symptoms that resemble dementia always mean the person has dementia.Depression and delirium can produce similar symptoms.
A person with dementia cannot also have depression.Depression and dementia can occur together.
Someone with ADRD who appears depressed must have depression.Early ADRD can produce behaviours resembling depression even when depression is not present.
Depression always looks the same in everyone.Depression symptoms may differ in people with ADRD.